Methods of quantitative and qualitative analyses of ancient marble finds assemblages. The cases of early Byzantine Hawara, Porphyreon, and Philoxenite
2023, 32, No. 1
University of Warsaw, Faculty of Archaeology
University of Warsaw, Polish Centre of Mediterranean Archaeology
University of Archaeology, Polish Centre of Mediterranean Archaeology
Publication date
Publishing model
License type
Field
Discipline
Language of publication
Downloads
PDF 1 MB
Number of views:347
Number of downloads:100
Crossref citations:0
Altmetric score:0
Abstract
Quantitative and qualitative analyses of marble finds at ancient sites are rare, one of the reasons being the lack of standard measures enabling comparison of different assemblages. The paper discusses the applicability and limitations of various methods of quantitative and qualitative analyses, which were tested on datasets of marble objects and excavation results from three medium-sized early Byzantine settlements: Hawara, Porphyreon, and Philoxenite. The tests involved the comparison of volume measurement results obtained for different functional and material-based classes of objects. The analyses confirmed a significant variability among the assemblages, which seems to have been related to the diverse geographic location and socio-religious significance of the settlements. Besides proving the applicability of the methods used, the study has indicated their potential for use in reconstructing consumption patterns in various types of settlements and investigating their intra- and supra-regional diversity.
Keywords:
Bibliography
Didymus Alexandrinus, Mensurae marmorum ac lignorum (F.O. Hultsch, ed.). Berlin: Weidmannos, 1864
Alcock, S.E. and Cherry, J.F. (eds). (2004). Side-by-side survey: Comparative regional studies in the Mediterranean world. Oxford: Oxbow
Allan, J. (1983). Some post-medieval documentary evidence for the trade in ceramics. In P. Davey and R. Hodges (eds), Ceramics and trade: The production and distribution of later medieval pottery in North-West Europe (pp. 37–45). Sheffield: Department of Prehistory and Archaeology, University of Sheffield
Asgari, N. (1995). The Proconnesian production of architectural elements in late antiquity, based on evidence from the marble quarries. In C.A. Mango, G. Dagron, and G. Greatrex, Constantinople and its hinterland: Papers from the Twenty-seventh Spring Symposium of Byzantine Studies, Oxford, April 1993 (=Society for the Promotion of Byzantine Studies Publications 3) (pp. 263–288). Aldershot: Variorum
Attanasio, D., Bruno, M., Prochaska, W., and Yavuz, A.B. (2015). Analysis and discrimination of Phrygian and other pavonazzetto-like marbles. In P. Pensabene and E. Gasparini (eds), Interdisciplinary studies on ancient stone: ASMOSIA X. Proceedings of the Tenth International Conference of ASMOSIA, Association for the Study of Marble & Other Stones in Antiquity, Rome, 21–26 May 2012 (pp. 753–764). Rome: “L’Erma” di Bretschneider
Attanasio, D., Bruno, M., and Yavuz, A.B. (2009). Quarries in the region of Aphrodisias: The black and white marbles of Göktepe (Muğla). Journal of Roman Archaeology, 22, 312–348
Attanasio, D., Yavuz, A.B., Bruno, M., Herrmann, J.J., Jr., Tykot, R.H., and van den Hoek, A. (2012). On the Ephesian origin of greco scritto marble. In A. Gutiérrez Garcia-M., P. Lapuente Mercadal, and I. Rodà de Llanza (eds), Interdisciplinary studies on ancient stone: Proceedings of the IX Association for the Study of Marbles and other Stones in Antiquity (ASMOSIA) conference (Tarragona 2009) (pp. 245–254). Tarragona: ICAC
Babraj, K., Drzymuchowska, A., and Tarara, D. (2020). The 5th-century Great Transept Basilica in “Marea”, Egypt, and the 4th-century predecessor church discovered in 2018. In K. Myśliwiec and A. Ryś (eds), Crossing time and space: To commemorate Hanna Szymańska (pp. 11–34). Warsaw–Wiesbaden: IKŚiO PAN; Harrassowitz Verlag
Ballance, M.H. (1966). The origin of africano. Papers of the British School at Rome, 34, 79–81
Berti, F. and Peirano, D. (2023). New research on Iasian marble. In A.B. Yavuz, B. Yolaçan, and M. Bruno (eds), ASMOSIA XII. Proceedings of the XII. ASMOSIA International Conference of 8–14 October 2018, Izmir, Dokuz Eylül University, Desem Halls, İzmir-Türkiye (pp. 3–12). Izmir: Dokuz Eylül University
Borghini, G. (ed.). (1997). Marmi antichi. Rome: Edizioni De Luca
Bruno, M., Elçi, H., Yavuz, A.B., and Attanasio, D. (2012). Unknown ancient marble quarries of western Asia Minor. In A. Gutiérrez Garcia-M., P. Lapuente Mercadal, and I. Rodà de Llanza (eds), Interdisciplinary studies on ancient stone: Proceedings of the IX Association for the Study of Marbles and other Stones in Antiquity (ASMOSIA) conference (Tarragona 2009) (pp. 562–572). Tarragona: ICAC
Contenau, G. (1920). Mission archéologique a Sidon: quatrième article. Syria, 1, 287–317
Corcoran, S. and DeLaine, J. (1994). The unit measurement of marble in Diocletian’s Prices Edict. Journal of Roman Archaeology, 7, 263–273
Dennert, M. and Westphalen, S. (2004). Säulen aus Konstantinopel: ein Schiffsfund im antiken Hafen von Amrit. Damaszener Mitteilungen, 14, 183–195
Derda, T., Gwiazda, M., Misiewicz, K., and Małkowski, W. (2021). Marea/Northern Hawwariya in northern Egypt: Integrated results of non-invasive and excavation works. Archaeological Prospection, 28(2), 123–136
el-Fakharani, F. (1983). Recent excavations at Marea in Egypt. In Das Römisch-Byzantinische Ägypten: Akten des internationalen Symposions 26.–30. September 1978 in Trier (=Aegyptiaca Treverensia 2) (pp. 175–186). Mainz am Rhein: Philipp von Zabern
Gadot, Y. and Adler, Y. (2016). A quantitative analysis of Jewish chalk vessel frequencies in early Roman Jerusalem: A view from the city’s garbage dump. Israel Exploration Journal, 66(2), 202–219
Gerstinger, H., Öllacher, H., and Vogel, K. (1932). Griechische literarische Papyri I. Vienna: Österreichische Staatsdruckerei
Gwiazda, M. (2014). Marble vessels from Jiyeh (Porphyreon). Polish Archaeology in the Mediterranean, 23/1, 527–542
Gwiazda, M. (2015). The marble decoration of the presbytery of the late antique basilica in Jiyeh (Porphyreon) – Lebanon. Światowit, 12(53)/A, 127–142
Gwiazda, M. (2023a). Dataset of marble finds from Hawara. Zenodo repository:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7507983
Gwiazda, M. (2023b). Dataset of marble finds from Philoxenite. Zenodo repository:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7508068
Gwiazda, M. (2023c). Dataset of marble finds from Porphyreon. Zenodo repository:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7508024
Gwiazda, M. and Derda, T. (2021). Marea: A swan song of ancient urban planning. Antiquity, 95(382).
https://doi.org/10.15184/aqy.2021.88
Gwiazda, M., Derda, T., and Barański, T. (2022). From Roman industrial center to early Islamic town: Archaeological excavations at ʻMarea’/Philoxenite in the 2020–2021 season. Polish Archaeology in the Mediterranean, 31, 333–373
Gwiazda, M., Piątkowska-Małecka, J., Wicenciak, U., Makowski, P., and Barański, T. (2021). The Sidon’s/Sạydā northern hinterland during the early Byzantine–early Islamic transition. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, 385, 171–200
Gwiazda, M. and Wielgosz-Rondolino, D. (2019). ‘Marea’ on Lake Mareotis: A Roman amphorae dump, a Byzantine period house, and its early Islamic dwellers. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology, 105(2), 259–273
Harrell, J.A. (2016). Table 2: Ancient Egyptian softstone quarries. Retrieved from http://www.eeescience.utoledo.edu/Faculty/Harrell/Egypt/Quarries/Softst_Quar.html (accessed: 05.06.2023)
İlhan, S. (2014). Restaurierung im Marmorsaal 31. In H. Thür and E. Rathmayr (eds), Hanghaus 2 in Ephesos: die Wohneinheit 6. Baubefund, Ausstattung, Funde II (=Forschungen in Ephesos 8/9) (pp. 803–829). Vienna: Verlag der Österreichischen Akademie der Wissenschaften
Jastrzębowska, E. (2018–2019). Überlegungen zu spätantiken korinthischen Kapitellen aus Alexandria, ausgehend von neuen Funden in Marea (Ägypten). Boreas, 41–42, 89–104
Klemm, R. and Klemm, D.D. (1993). Steine und Steinbrüche im Alten Ägypten. Berlin: Springer
Lazzarini, L. (1990). Rosso antico and other red marbles used in antiquity: A characterization study. In Marble: Art historical and scientific perspectives on ancient sculpture. Papers delivered at a symposium organized by the Departments of Antiquities and Antiquities Conservation and held at the J. Paul Getty Museum, April 28–30, 1988 (pp. 237–252). Malibu, CA: J. Paul Getty Museum
Lazzarini, L. (2002). The origin and characterization of breccia nuvolata, marmor sagarium, and marmor triponticum. In J. Herrmann, N. Herz, and R. Newman (eds), ASMOSIA 5: Interdisciplinary studies on ancient stone. Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference of the Association for the Study of Marble and Other Stones in Antiquity, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, 1998 (pp. 58–67). London: Archetype
Lazzarini, L. (2007). Poikiloi lithoi, versiculores maculae: i marmi colorati della Grecia antica. Storia, uso, diffusione, cave, geologia, caratterizzazione scientifica, archeometria, deterioramento (=Marmora. Supplemento 1). Pisa: F. Serra
Lazzarini, L., Antonelli, F., Cancelliere, S., Turi, B., and Varti Matarangas, M. (2002). Marmor Chalcidum (Fior di Pesco): Source, history of use and scientific characterization. In L. Lazzarini (ed.), Interdisciplinary studies on ancient stone: ASMOSIA VI. Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference of the Association for the Study of Marble and Other Stones in Antiquity, Venice, June 15–18, 2000 (pp. 233–240). Padua: Ausilio Editore
Lazzarini, L., Masi, U., and Tucci, P. (1995). Petrographic and geochemical features of the Carystian marble, ‘Cipollino verde’, from the ancient quarries of Southern Euboea (Greece). In Y. Maniatis, N. Herz, and Y. Basiakos (eds), ASMOSIA 3: The study of marble and other stones used in antiquity (pp. 161–169). London: Archetype
Leibner, U. (2014). Determining the settlement history of Hellenistic, Roman, and Byzantine sites in the Galilee, Israel: Comparing surface, subsurface, and stratified artifact assemblages. Journal of Field Archaeology, 39(4), 387–400
Lucci, M.L. (1964). Il porfido nell’antichita. Archeologia Classica, 16, 226–271
Lyman, R.L. (2008). Quantitative paleozoology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
Mills, P. (2013). The ancient Mediterranean trade in ceramic building materials: A case study in Carthage and Beirut (=Roman and Late Antique Mediterranean Pottery 2). Oxford: Archaeopress
Oleson, J.P. and Schick, R. (2013). Analysis and conclusions. In J.P. Oleson and R. Schick, Humayma excavation project II. Nabatean campground and necropolis, Byzantine churches, and early Islamic domestic structures (=American Schools of Oriental Research Archaeological Reports 18) (pp. 547–554). Boston: American Schools of Oriental Research
Orton, C. (1989). An introduction to the quantification of assemblages of pottery. Journal of Roman Pottery Studies, 2(2), 94–97
Pensabene, P. (2002). Le principali cave di marmo bianco. In M. De Nuccio and L. Ungaro (eds), I marmi colorati della Roma imperiale (pp. 203–222). Venice: Marsilio
Pensabene, P., González de Andrés, L., and Atienza Fuente, J. (2015). A quantitative and qualitative study on marble revetments of service area in the Villa del Casale at Piazza Armerina. In P. Pensabene and E. Gasparini (eds), Interdisciplinary studies on ancient stone: ASMOSIA X. Proceedings of the Tenth International Conference of ASMOSIA, Association for the Study of Marble & Other Stones in Antiquity, Rome, 21–26 May 2012, I (pp. 641–649). Rome: “L’Erma” di Bretschneider
Rekowska, M. (2019–2020). From Beirut to Sidon: The coastal road described by Westerner travellers (17th–19th centuries). Archaeology & History in Lebanon, 50–51, 199–214
Röder, G. (1988). Numidian marble and some of its specialities. In N. Herz and M. Waelkens (eds), Classical marble: Geochemistry, technology, trade (pp. 91–96). Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic
Röder, J. (1971). Marmor Phrygium: die antiken Marmorbrüche von İscehisar in Westanatolien. Jahrbuch des Deutschen Archäologischen Instituts, 86, 253–312
Schick, R., Oleson, J.P., al-Bashaireh, K., Graf, D.F., Herz, N., and Rowe, G.D. (2013). Ecclesiastical marble, inscriptions, and miscellaneous stone finds. In J.P. Oleson and R. Schick, Humayma excavation project II. Nabatean campground and necropolis, Byzantine churches, and early Islamic domestic structures (=American Schools of Oriental Research Archaeological Reports 18) (pp. 449–515). Boston: American Schools of Oriental Research
Szymańska, H. and Babraj, K. (eds). (2008). Marea I. Byzantine Marea: Excavations in 2000–2003 and 2006 (=Biblioteka Muzeum Archeologicznego w Krakowie 4). Kraków: Muzeum Archeologiczne w Krakowie
Tomber, R. (1993). Quantitative approaches to the investigation of long-distance exchange. Journal of Roman Archaeology, 6, 142–166
Tůmová, H., Augenti, A., Kuchařová, A., Cirelli, E., and Přikryl, R. (2016). Late antique marble trade: New insights obtained from stone artefacts from the San Severo complex (Ravenna, Italy). In R. Přikryl, Á. Török, M. Gómez-Heras, K. Miskovsky, and M. Theodoridou (eds), Sustainable use of traditional geomaterials in construction practice (pp. 35–46). London: The Geological Society
Waliszewski, T. and Gwiazda, M. (2015). Porphyreon through the ages: The fading archaeological heritage of the Lebanese coast. Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology & Heritage Studies, 3(4), 330–348
Wielgosz-Rondolino, D., Antonelli, F., Bojanowski, M.J., Gładki, M., Göncüoğlu, M.C., and Lazzarini, L. (2020). Improved methodology for identification of Göktepe white marble and the understanding of its use: A comparison with Carrara marble. Journal of Archaeological Science, 113, 105059.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2019.105059
Zezza, U. and Lazzarini, L. (2002). Krokeatis Lithos (Lapis Lacedaemonius): Source, history of use, scientific characterization. In L. Lazzarini (ed.), Interdisciplinary studies on ancient stone: ASMOSIA VI. Proceedings of the sixth international conference of the Association for the Study of Marble and Other Stones in Antiquity, Venice, June 15–18, 2000 (pp. 259–264). Padua: Bottega d’Erasmo
Other articles from the issue
- marbleEarly ByzantineEastern Mediterranean
Foreword
- Halasarna of KosProkonnesosmarblequarriesbowls
Early Byzantine vases carved in Prokonnesian marble from ancient Halasarna (Kos Island, Dodecanese, Greece)
- Late Antique and Early Byzantine marble furnishingsmasons’ marksstonecutters’ marksmultiple marksstone workshopsbuilding sitesConstantinople cisternsHagia Sophia
Multiple stonecutters’ marks on marble in the Late Antique Mediterranean: distribution, function, and meaning
Similar publications
- marbleEarly ByzantineEastern Mediterranean
Foreword
- Halasarna of KosProkonnesosmarblequarriesbowls
Early Byzantine vases carved in Prokonnesian marble from ancient Halasarna (Kos Island, Dodecanese, Greece)
- Late Antique and Early Byzantine marble furnishingsmasons’ marksstonecutters’ marksmultiple marksstone workshopsbuilding sitesConstantinople cisternsHagia Sophia
Multiple stonecutters’ marks on marble in the Late Antique Mediterranean: distribution, function, and meaning